We're the student's union of 30,000 students at Leeds University and we're currently getting excited about Freshers' Week 2014! Our clubs, bars and events are essential to student life!

Should the Union boycott Israeli goods?

Rated 4/5 (20 people). Log in to rate.


Name of proposer:

Irial Eno


Idea Title:

Should the Union boycott Israeli goods?


What the idea is about:

Remove Israeli goods (such as sweet peppers and oranges) from the Union co-operative shelves, and prevent other Union food outlets from selling Israeli products.


Why have you proposed it?:

Israeli settlements are illegal under rulings of the International Court of Justice, UN Resolution 446, the Fourth Geneva Convention and, overwhelmingly, the international community, including the EU and the UK.

Gaza, the West Bank and East Jerusalem are all under an illegal occupation by Israel, which profits from exporting goods, including fruits, vegetables and herbs grown in illegal settlements on stolen Palestinian land into the UK.

Most British supermarkets, including the Co-op, now claim to no longer stock goods from illegal settlements. However, they continue to source products from within internationally recognised Israeli borders, from companies that also profit from exporting settlement goods. The sale of products from these companies help to sustain their operations in the settlements.

In supporting companies that also sell illegal settlement goods, our Union is complicit in violations of international law and the colonisation of Palestinian lands.

In a historic move, the National Union of Students (NUS) in the UK has thrown its weight behind campaigns targeting companies complicit in Israel's occupation and breaches of international law. The TUC has also passed a landmark policy to boycott all companies complicit in the illegal occupation. The universities of Edinburgh, Cambridge, Manchester, Kings College London and London School of Economics, amongst others, have all passed motions boycotting Israeli produce.

Archbishop Desmond Tutu said of his trip to Palestine:

'I've been very deeply distressed in my visit to the Holy Land; it reminded me so much of what happened to us black people in South Africa. I have seen the humiliation of the Palestinians at checkpoints and roadblocks, suffering like us when young white police officers prevented us from moving about'.

I believe our union has a moral responsibility to heed the call of the oppressed people, like so many university campuses did against South African apartheid in the eighties.




The Panel voted on this Idea:


Yes 4 No 10


This Idea has gone to Referendum


Please login to comment.

Nelly Pramuditha
10:56am on 19 Aug 14 You'll find normally absolutely a good amount of facts that will adheres fot it take into account. Which is a excellent specify improve up. You can expect the actual concepts previously mentioned since typical creativeness but evidently you'll find inquiries such as the one particular persons improve up where by the most important thing will likely be receiving operate carried out with honest effective rely on. Many of us use? testo-sterone degrees find out if perhaps best practices get occur around such things as that could, but Almost certainly that a distinct undertaking is usually evidently termed as a superb activity. Both kids contain the impression involving simply a moment’s fulfillment, with the unwind with the lifestyles. An exceptional select, My spouse and i just together with all this along with the actual relate who had previously been basically accomplishing a smaller research due to this. Along with they in reality obtained us lunch time for the reason that I stumbled upon this intended for your pet.. seem. And so i need to reword that could: Thnx with the handle! Nonetheless sure Thnkx intended for paying whenever to debate this, I am just highly over it and luxuriate in evaluating additional due to this subject matter. Whenever, whenever you develop into practical knowledge, really does a single head bringing up-to-date your website to comprehend facts? It may be particularly a great choice to me professionally. Important universal series bus up wards for this document!. you do have a quite excellent internet site right here! must you help to make a few acquire blogposts with our internet site?
Betty Brown
11:56pm on 16 Aug 14 However, it makes excellent pancakes, and when used in sauces/rousses, it's basically indistinguishable from flour. And in that role, I believe the Capresso does an outstanding job for the money. nothing else gives the pump or the energy to go to extreme heights. The quantity should be double what these are and the price should be half what they're charging now. Q10 Vitamin Coenzyme Best Coq10 Uk The compact size of this seat and its amazing safety ratings sealed the deal. This is one of the easiest sergers that I have owned to thread. There really isn't much to say about printer ink other then it seems to be expensive for what you get. Best Coq10 Uk Coenzyme Q10. Learn more Nutri Nano Coq10 Solgar
Gufron Fitriono
4:05pm on 30 Jul 14 Yes sir sometimes but its the opportunity to correct our mistake if someone criticize for work I will take it as positive way and will give positive result. Through it we can learn lot of things. And we can rectify the mistakes.saranapoker agen texas poker dan domino online indonesia terpercaya | nagalaut agen judi bola online piala dunia 2014, sbobet, ibcbet terbaik dan terpercaya di indonesia | bundapoker agen texas poker dan domino online indonesia terpercaya | Situs Judi Poker Online Terbaik Terpercaya | safety url monetize | Hosting Unlimited dan Domain Murah Terbaik di Indonesia | Arbnew | Mr Remoxp - Daftar Harga Sony
Randy Randy
12:18pm on 8 Jul 14 wow ... this is a very good article and useful, allow me to share it, I will try to share this link for our mutual benefit. Agen Bola | STARBALL88 | Agen Sbobet | Prediksi Bola | Berita Bola | Prediksi Skor | Prediksi Bola | Prediksi Bola | Agen Poker Online | Judi Poker Online | Agen Bola Terbaik thank you.
Betty Brown
6:55am on 30 Jun 14 Like Swift, she can be wickedly funny. It is easy to use, simple to adjust the flow and water temp. ok i thought to give it a go with this pills, i did read most of the reviews about the results and what not, at first i did felt a little bit of sensation around the nipple area and it did give them a bit of fullnes and firm but didn't see ''enlargment'' at all they're the same size :( my sexual enhancement is the same not difference there iether, so i thoug it was because the coffee but it couldnt since i only drink decaf and only one cup any other day but i wish it actually worked but not so much luck here, a bit disapointed about it Ehrenreich artfully analyzes the positive psychology mania, placing it in historical perspective and evaluating its claims systematically. Nutrilite Omega 3 Spread Dha Omega 3 600 Mg I certainly recommend them - they accomplish what you need them to accomplish. If you see these marked down, pick them up. Tonight I went to use it as a substitute for a laminate trimmer and it "stalled" ,,, as the manual says ,, then failed to turn on 15 minutes later. Dha Omega 3 600 Mg Omega 3 VGCS. Visit site Omega 3 Foods That Are Not Fish
Betty Brown
12:25am on 27 Jun 14 I have had it for more than 2 years and mechanically it works flawlessly. I find this model is a lot quicker at epilating, it grabs the hairs nicely and gets the really short ones no problems. This new one is perfect, quiet, and shaves really well. The stand itself is an excellent design. Cvs Probiotic Coupon Do Probiotics Reduce Candida The single-player game is mediocre at best. Although, I tended to use the spindle lock and one wrench instead of both wrenches. I cant wash much in it, like only a pair of pants, or about 3 t-shirts etc. Do Probiotics Reduce Candida Visit site Vegan Probiotics Recipe
Tommy Syatriadi
5:09pm on 18 Jun 14 contoh paragraf deskripsi Tujuan Pembangunan Nasional akibat rotasi bumi great post
Betty Brown
12:33pm on 16 Jun 14 there is a design flaw that makes these worthless after 6-12 months. I have had this Shaver for a month now and I must say it is the best one yet of the 2 that I previously owned prior to this one. This exact model, brought in by a customer hoping it could be repaired, was on display with its housing opened to show how cheap the internal workings are. Cuisinart and Breville both do this. Does Spirulina Powder Have A Taste Zoo Med Spirulina 20 Ingredients This product is a good product, however the packaging or seal around the top lid was or seemed secure. I put it on every morning after shower, and my skin absorbs it right away. And in a little less than a month, too! My hair is growing faster and thicker and I can feel little hairs cropping up on my head in places where there had been just bare skin before. Zoo Med Spirulina 20 Ingredients Learn more Spirulina In Fish Feed
Sutopo Sasuke
12:17am on 30 May 14 harga motor terbaru yamaha harga motor terbaru Suzuki harga motor terbaru Ducati harga motor terbaru Honda harga motor terbaru TVS harga motor terbaru Kawasaki harga Motor Teraru Harley Davidson Modifikasi motor terbaru yamaha Modifikasi motor terbaru Suzuki Modifikasi motor terbaru Ducati Modifikasi motor terbaru Honda Modifikasi motor terbaru TVS Modifikasi motor terbaru Kawasaki Modifikasi Motor Teraru Harley Davidson Aksesoris Motor Tips Motor
Betty Brown
1:23pm on 29 May 14 I also like it because its not full of tons of junk. Though following the diet is a roaring PITA(!), do it. If you are a waxer looking to save some money, I highly recommend this. The main difference between the two if the graphics resolution, which is expected. Probiotics Cured My Psoriasis Probiotic Yogurt Or Tablets Afterwards my skin was SO smooth and even the short coarse hairs that I usually struggle with were removed. After my initial hair removal, I use it as hairs start coming in, so I remove less, and never have the annoying phase where the hair is visible but not quite long enough to wax. I used to make black and tans and half and half's years ago with a bent spoon or even just angling the glass and if I remember correctly I got much better separation than with this turtle. Probiotic Yogurt Or Tablets Learn more Probiotics Candida Support
Betty Brown
6:51am on 24 May 14 We use linux, windows, and mac in the house and all were set up and printing quickly to this unit. What arrived from this manufacturer was even worse. Another bore." But at the end of the book, we find out that Elio had deliberately picked out Oliver, based on his photo, from a number of other candidates. Not wanting to return to more drugs, I immediately bought the book and started Katera on the SCD (April '03). I Forgot To Take My Prenatal Vitamins Prenatal The urine in the box is the biggest problem for ANY litter device. The strips did the trick with the first one, I could not believe I woke up eight hours later fully rested. All the reviews regarding bad smell are correct. St Joseph Hospital Prenatal Care Prenatal Diagnosis Of Vacterl Read more
Arl Seo
11:43am on 7 May 14 A great experience Jasa SEO
Graham Drum
1:31pm on 5 May 14 This issue is more related to government level decisions and making decision on small level will not deliver desired results. Big companies are getting benefit of the situation and use resources of such areas to make profit. I am not sure removing Israeli goods will be helpful for us to deliver our message. Thanks infographic design agency
Tommy Syatriadi
2:27pm on 4 Apr 14 bisnis modal kecil game ps2 rpg terbaik download aplikasi android apk great post
Didin Muktamar
4:08am on 2 Apr 14 I really enjoyed the article. It proved to be Very helpful to me and I am sure to all the commenters here! It’s always nice when you can not only be informed, but also entertained Medium Hairstyles 2014
Arl Seo
3:26am on 28 Mar 14 A great experience Pulau Tidung-Cuci Sofa
Arl Seo
1:13am on 27 Mar 14 A great experience Cap Kaki Tiga, Setia, Manfaat-Jasa SEO
Sutopo Sasuke
4:09pm on 13 Mar 14 I appreciate yourwork. I’ve been looking for quite some time such an useful resource and I’m very glad I found it. Keep up the good work Jasa SEO Jogja Pakar SEO Jogja Superwash Laundry Bisnis Franchise Waralaba Murah di Indonesia
Sutopo Sasuke
6:11pm on 3 Mar 14 Very good post! We are linking to this particularly great content on our website. Keep up the good writing. obat pembesar penis alami, vimax asli pembesar penis alami,cara memperbesar penis,pembesar penis alami
Kane Paul
6pm on 26 Feb 14 We have seen many such campaigns which resulted to into result. There is a need to set rules for everyone and even big players have to follow them. Its necessary if we want this world a safe place. United Nations is not as good as it is supposed to be in protecting the rights of UN member countries. Thanks essay writing service reviews
Arl Seo
12:40am on 31 Jan 14 A great post!!Krokodil Drug
Arl Seo
4:38am on 30 Jan 14 Thanks for such a knowledgeable post. Baju Muslim
Arl Seo
1:30pm on 28 Jan 14 Thanks for such a knowledgeable post. Harga Laptop Terbaru Home Design Decors
Arl Seo
7:59am on 24 Jan 14 Thanks for such a knowledgeable post. Giztekno Jasa SEO .
Arl Seo
4:50am on 24 Jan 14 A great post!!Jasa SEO|Jasa SEO Murah|Krokodil Drug
Andi Young
9:45am on 5 Oct 13 Simply wish to say your article is as surprising. The clarity in your post is just spectacular and i could assume you are an expert on this subject. Fine with your permission let me to grab your RSS feed to keep updated with forthcoming post. Thanks a million and please carry on the rewarding work. agen bola casino sbobet agen sbobet taruhan bola
Soon Hren
3:51pm on 8 Jul 13 Excellent, what a website it is! This weblog provides useful facts to us, keep it up. investir options binaires brokers
Leen Barghouti
5:16pm on 2 May 12 Finally, just to reiterate, there are many Israelis who support the boycott of Israeli goods, one notable is Ilan Pappe an academic, 'the Israeli occupation is a dynamic process and it becomes worse with each passing day. People can choose to stand by and do nothing, or to be part of a historical movement similar to the anti-apartheid campaign against the white supremacist regime in South Africa. By choosing the latter, it can move us forward along the only remaining viable and non-violent road to saving both Palestinians and Israelis from an impending catastrophe.' -Ilan Pappe, Israeli academic.
Leen Barghouti
5:13pm on 2 May 12 To suggest that such a motion marganilizes Israeli students and racist is to assume that there is liberty and equality within the Israeli society. Sure, settlements are illegal in international law, there is no contention surrounding that, even the US agrees on that and the 4th Geneva Convention reiterates that fact. But the situation at hand is, can we separate the Israeli government from the illegal settlement? Can we separate Israeli government from the occupation? This is in no way against any Israeli students, for many Israeli students, and not attack on Israeli citizens either. Just like the boycott of South African goods was not an attack on the white South African citizens. It is almost ridiculous to suggest that it would harm Palestinian business and Palestinian people. The root of the problem here is the occupation, and this motion aims to end cooperation with a state that is the occupier and has over 60 racist and discriminated policies. The boycott is not an attack on Israeli students, just like the UK's sanctions against Iran is not motivated by hatred for the Iranian people or racism, it is take a stance against the ongoing injustice and human rights. It took 20 years for the boycott of South African goods to gain moment and the argument against it was always 'it's far too complex, boycotting would not solve anything, etc', but it was student activism and boycotting that finally brought justice to South Africa.
Samuel Mohr
3:17pm on 2 May 12 This whole idea is simply unjustified and poorly thought out. Firstly the claims to apartheid are simply preposterous. Israel has a 20% Arab/Palestinian population with full democratic rights, and members of parliament and the only country in the middle east which protects gay rights and freedom of religion and expression. Yes I understand that a boycott of settlement produce might be justified due to illegalities of settlement building under international law. However calling for a boycott of all Israeli products is a discriminatory attack on the Israeli people and Israeli students. This view is further justified by the fact that the coop who supply essentials will not purchase produce from settlements or settlement linked companies. Therefore boycotting all Israeli produce fails to recognise the work of legitimate israeli business which we should be integrating not pushing away. A boycott of all Israeli produce could also include those purchased from Palestinian farmers and sold via Israel for example olive oil. You must also question where does it stop. Israel has given us mobile phones and the intel computer chip? If we are really serious about boycotting Israel maybe boycott those too? As James said where does this end? China too? As a student at Leeds I want to support Israel - surely we should have the free choice to buy whatever peppers we like? This proposal marginalises a number of students in order to please another, who could simply just choose not to buy the two or three things the union sells which are sourced from Israel.
Ramzi Cherad
11:46am on 2 May 12 Britain’s fifth-largest food retailers’ boycott on products from Israeli settlements
Aaron Cohen-Gold
7:52pm on 30 Apr 12 The answer should categorically be 'no'. The reasoning for this motion rests squarely with settlements, yet the motion then applies to Israel as a whole. Whilst a case for Aparthied in the West Bank is plausible (though hotly disputed an rightly so), it is absurd at best and racist at worst to assume that suggestion for israel as a whole. When considering the atrocities committed by Israel's neighbours vis a vis the Arab Spring in recent months, it makes no political sense to isolate Israel and ignore the far worse, far more stringent and far more brutal oppression suffered by those around the country being isolate in this motion. If, in this most controversial and complex of conflicts, settlements are a key issue then resulting political motions should be about them, not excused by them.
Samuel Brightbart
9:16pm on 25 Apr 12 I very much agree with what James says. Israel is one of the most prominent examples of a country that makes profit from settlements that are illegal under international law. They are therefore one of the most obvious choices for a boycott. It is not the case that they are being chosen arbitrarily over dozens of equally viable candidates for boycott.
James Killin
2:22pm on 24 Apr 12 There is already a tangible, successful BDS campaign against Israel, and that is the campaign from which this motion takes its inspiration. BDS is a Palestinian initiative, proposed to international communities, so rather than being what the above commenter seems to intimate is a ‘picking and choosing’ of which oppressed peoples to support, it is a response to an action that is already taking place. It is not a campaign to "attack" Israel, but a campaign to support Palestinian resistance. This is not an abstract, random proposal; there are many Palestinian students on campus who are directly affected by Israel’s actions, and the success of this motion would be a sign that the Union accepts this, and is working to limit its complicity in the on-going occupation of Palestine. If this policy could get people interested in campaigning against the crimes of the Israeli government, then it could also inspire them to go and work on other campaigns. It is not restrictive, but is rather a gateway to much more activism. I take issue with the suggestion that, if we cannot help everybody, it is too ‘sensitive’ an issue for us to think about helping anybody. If you truly believe that we all “want a better world,” then I would wholeheartedly urge you to seize an opportunity such as this.
James Hanson
7:18pm on 23 Apr 12 The problem is, where does this end? Do we not supply any Chinese made goods (and that is a heck of a lot) because of its undemocratic government and human rights violations. Of course we want a better world, but there are huge inconsistencies by suggesting it is right to ban produce from one regime, but not from another.
Conor Walsh
4:17pm on 23 Apr 12 A progressive policy. Well done.
Back to top